Chinese Researchers Propose Broadening the Search for Life to Incorporate Minerals Alongside Water

Chinese Researchers Propose Broadening the Search for Life to Incorporate Minerals Alongside Water


**Serpentines: A Fresh Blueprint in the Quest for Extraterrestrial Life**

The quest for extraterrestrial life has fascinated both scientists and the general public for many years. Historically, researchers have adhered to the principle of “follow the water,” based on the belief that liquid water is vital for life as we understand it. Nevertheless, a team of scientists from the Chinese Academy of Sciences, led by Wei Lin and Jianxun Shen, is introducing a groundbreaking enhancement to this investigation strategy: instead of merely seeking water, they propose searching for minerals known as serpentines—a significant indicator in identifying hospitable environments beyond our planet.

### What Are Serpentines?

Serpentines consist of a class of hydrated silicate minerals characterized by the general chemical formula (X)₂₋₃(Y)₂O₅(OH)₄. In this formula, X may include elements such as magnesium, iron, nickel, aluminum, zinc, or manganese, while Y is predominantly silicon, aluminum, or iron. These minerals arise from a transformative geological process termed **serpentinisation**, during which igneous rocks, rich in olivine and orthopyroxene, undergo a chemical reaction with water.

This process is significant for multiple reasons:

1. **Sign of Liquid Water and Warm Conditions**: Serpentinisation generally takes place in environments with liquid water and relatively elevated temperatures, both crucial factors in crafting potentially habitable conditions.

2. **Production of Hydrogen Gas**: The alteration of minerals during serpentinisation yields hydrogen gas—a powerful energy source for microbial life in subterranean settings on Earth.

3. **Promotion of Organic Chemistry**: Byproducts resulting from serpentinisation, such as hydrogen, methane, and ammonia, participate in chemical reactions necessary for the formation of organic compounds. These compounds are fundamental to life, as illustrated in the well-known **Miller-Urey experiment**, which demonstrated that the precursors of life can emerge in lab settings that replicate early Earth conditions.

### Serpentines as Biomarkers Beyond Earth

Lin and Shen assert that serpentines could act as indicators of life-supporting environments. Their presence may signal locations where vital compounds, energy sources, and conditions for preservation converge. Notably, serpentines are not exclusive to Earth; they are prevalent throughout the solar system. These minerals have been identified on Mars, asteroids, meteorites, and potentially on icy moons like Europa and Enceladus (around Jupiter) and Titan (around Saturn). The presence of hydrogen in the atmospheres of these celestial bodies reinforces the argument for integrating serpentinisation into the search for extraterrestrial life.

### Why Emphasize Serpentines?

The concept of employing serpentines as a diagnostic tool for identifying habitable environments rises from the acknowledgment that “following the water” has its limitations. Water is essential for life, yet its existence does not suffice to ensure livable conditions or the presence of life. Serpentines offer a more sophisticated marker since their formation intrinsically connects water, geochemical energy sources (like hydrogen), and the possibility of organic compounds coexisting.

As Shen notes: *“The occurrence of serpentine provides insights into the presence of various critical life-supporting compounds, energy sources, and preservation conditions. A site abundant in serpentine minerals could offer conditions suitable for extraterrestrial life.”*

The capacity of serpentines to engage in crucial reactions, such as converting CO₂ into methane or forming amino acids alongside specific minerals, highlights their biochemical significance.

### Challenges and Limitations

Although the potential role of serpentines is highly encouraging, several challenges must be tackled before this method can emerge as a practical tool in astrobiology:

1. **Subsurface Location**: Most serpentines lie below planetary surfaces within rock formations, making direct detection challenging. Dirk Schulze-Makuch, an astrobiologist from the Technical University of Berlin, emphasizes that this limitation renders the identification of serpentines more feasible on Mars than on icy moons like Europa or Enceladus, not to mention distant exoplanets.

2. **Complexity of Planetary Chemistry**: The existence of hydrogen, methane, ammonia, and organic molecules could stem from various abiotic processes apart from serpentinisation. Distinguishing whether these features arise from biological or non-biological processes will demand further data and advanced instrumentation.

3. **Technological Challenges**: Current and upcoming technologies might not fully support the remote detection of serpentines, especially on exoplanets. Most efforts will rely on spectroscopy from orbital spacecraft and robotic landers, or eventually on sample return missions for detailed laboratory examination.

### Potential Applications in Planetary Science

Despite these hurdles, Lin and Shen contend that serpentines could steer the choice of future landing sites in astrobiology missions. For instance:

– On Mars, regions with considerable serpentine-rich rock masses could be prioritized in the search for biosignatures or preserved organic materials.
– On icy moons