### Hydrogen-Powered Vehicles: Are They the Key to Sustainable Mobility?
In 2028, BMW is set to introduce its inaugural hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicle (FCEV), the iX5 Hydrogen, declaring hydrogen cars as the “key element” in the quest for sustainable mobility. On the surface, hydrogen-powered vehicles appear to offer the advantages of battery electric vehicles (BEVs)—including zero tailpipe emissions—while providing considerably quicker refueling times: merely three to four minutes. However, the enthusiasm surrounding hydrogen vehicles is moderated by hurdles in production, infrastructure, and efficiency. Although some car manufacturers remain hopeful about a hydrogen-centric future, others contend that BEVs have already secured their position in the effort to decarbonize passenger transport.
This division raises a pressing question: Will hydrogen be the energy source of the future, or is the concept of hydrogen vehicles beginning to fade?
—
### Understanding Hydrogen Power: The Mechanism
A hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicle operates similarly to a battery electric vehicle regarding its drivetrain—both utilize electric motors for propulsion. The principal distinction lies in the method of electricity generation.
Rather than relying on a large battery to accumulate energy, hydrogen-powered vehicles generate electricity on demand by converting hydrogen gas through a chemical reaction in the fuel cell. Here’s the process:
1. **Hydrogen Storage and Fuel Cells**: Hydrogen is stored in high-pressure containers and delivered to the fuel cell.
2. **Electrochemical Reaction**: Within the fuel cell, hydrogen interacts with oxygen sourced from the atmosphere, generating electricity. A platinum catalyst separates the hydrogen atoms into protons and electrons. The protons travel through an electrolyte membrane to the cathode, while the electrons create an electric current as they navigate through an external circuit.
3. **Clean Byproduct**: The interaction at the cathode combines protons, electrons, and oxygen, resulting in water vapor, the sole byproduct.
For motorists, FCEVs offer clear benefits over BEVs. Refueling a hydrogen vehicle takes approximately the same time as topping off a gasoline car—less than five minutes—compared to the prolonged charging times of BEVs, which can range from 30 minutes to over 12 hours based on battery capacity and charging station performance. Additionally, FCEVs maintain dependable performance in extreme cold, unlike BEVs, whose battery efficiency may decline in frigid conditions.
A standard hydrogen vehicle, like Toyota’s Mirai or Hyundai’s Nexo, can cover around 310 miles on 6 kg of hydrogen, making them especially appealing for drivers covering long distances or in areas lacking extensive charging infrastructure.
—
### Obstacles Facing Hydrogen Vehicles
Despite the evident advantages of hydrogen vehicles in specific aspects, significant challenges persist, casting doubt on their feasibility for widespread adoption:
#### 1. **Hydrogen Production: Not Environmentally Friendly Enough**
Hydrogen may be the most plentiful element in the cosmos, but generating it on Earth in an eco-friendly manner poses considerable challenges. Currently, the majority of hydrogen is produced through methods such as steam methane reforming or coal gasification, both of which emit substantial amounts of carbon dioxide. This type of hydrogen, referred to as “gray hydrogen,” undermines the environmental perks of FCEVs.
“Green hydrogen,” created by utilizing renewable energy to electrolyze water into hydrogen and oxygen, is deemed the preferred solution. Nevertheless, it remains costly and energy-intensive. Until green hydrogen can compete in price with hydrogen derived from fossil fuels, the carbon footprint of hydrogen-powered cars may exceed that of gasoline or diesel vehicles.
#### 2. **Energy Conversion Inefficiencies**
Hydrogen fuel cells are fundamentally less efficient than their BEV counterparts. The processes of creating hydrogen, transporting it, and converting it back into electricity entail multiple stages where energy is lost. Even the most efficient hydrogen fuel cells achieve around 60% efficiency, whereas BEV powertrains can reach 90% efficiency.
Frank Hodgson, a senior energy analyst at Regen, explains: “You’re losing energy along the way, which adds to costs. The theoretical maximum efficiency [of fuel cells] is 83%, and no engineering can enhance this. The laws of thermodynamics dictate that it will always be a relatively inefficient powertrain.”
#### 3. **Insufficient Refueling Infrastructure**
A major obstacle for hydrogen vehicles is the lack of refueling stations. Currently, the UK has fewer than ten operational hydrogen stations, and even some of those have shut down due to minimal demand. For hydrogen vehicles to succeed, considerable investment in infrastructure is necessary, which has yet to occur.
Manufacturers such as Toyota and Hyundai originally anticipated that governmental and energy enterprises would invest in hydrogen refueling networks, but advancements have been sluggish. Without a dependable infrastructure, the promise of a 400-mile range becomes irrelevant if drivers are unable to locate a refueling point.