For countless individuals grappling with depression, the decision among medication, therapy, or alternative options can feel overwhelming. A thorough review of 73 studies indicates that engaging in physical activity merits serious consideration alongside conventional treatments, demonstrating effectiveness similar to psychological therapy in alleviating symptoms.
Researchers from the University of Lancashire analyzed nearly 5,000 adults suffering from depression across numerous randomized studies. Those assigned to exercise programs exhibited moderate reductions in symptoms compared to those who received no treatment. Interestingly, when exercise was directly compared to psychological therapy in ten studies, the results were remarkably similar. The comparison with antidepressant medication also indicated comparable effectiveness, although fewer studies have explored this comparison, and the evidence remains less definitive.
These findings do not suggest that exercise is a one-size-fits-all solution. While side effects were uncommon, they included occasional musculoskeletal injuries, and individuals on antidepressants like sertraline reported fatigue, gastrointestinal issues, and sexual dysfunction. What exercise provides is adaptability in a realm where patient preference is exceptionally important.
Not every form of movement is equally effective
The review pinpointed patterns where certain exercise methods appeared most advantageous. Light to moderate intensity activities surpassed vigorous workouts, and completing between 13 to 36 sessions linked to improved outcomes. Mixed exercise routines and resistance training seemed to be more effective than aerobic exercise alone, although no single type was distinctly superior.
“Exercise can assist individuals with depression, but to determine which types are most effective, for whom, and if the benefits endure over time, we still require larger, high-quality studies,” states Professor Andrew Clegg. “One large, well-executed trial is far more valuable than many low-quality small trials.”
This caution permeates the research. Most included studies were small, with fewer than 100 participants, and many possessed methodological flaws. Only 22 adequately concealed their randomization process, merely 31 utilized intention-to-treat analyses, and just 23 had blinded outcome assessors. The studies assessed outcomes at the conclusion of treatment, but few monitored participants long enough to ascertain whether benefits are maintained.
A treatment that integrates into daily life
Depression impacts over 280 million individuals globally, making it a primary contributor to disability. Exercise incurs minimal costs, requires no prescription, and offers cardiovascular and metabolic advantages that medications cannot replicate. For some patients, the real obstacle isn’t access, but rather finding motivation during depressive phases when even minor tasks seem daunting.
This update incorporated 35 new trials into versions published in 2008 and 2013; however, the central conclusion has remained consistent: exercise provides significant benefits for certain individuals with depression. What remains unclear is which individuals respond optimally, which attributes of exercise are most crucial, and whether the effects last beyond the treatment phase. The review was unable to evaluate practices such as yoga or qigong that many currently utilize but were excluded from the analysis.
For patients and clinicians considering their options, the evidence repositions physical activity not as an auxiliary wellness practice, but as a genuine therapeutic resource that performs on par with established interventions. Discovering a method that a person can realistically maintain may be more important than fine-tuning a specific exercise regimen.
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews: [10.1002/14651858.CD004366.pub7](https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD004366.pub7)
There’s no paywall here
If our reporting has educated or motivated you, please think about making a donation. Every contribution, no matter how small, empowers us to continue offering accurate, engaging, and trustworthy scientific and medical news. Independent journalism demands time, effort, and resources—your support ensures we can keep uncovering the stories that matter most to you.
Join us in making knowledge accessible and influential. Thank you for standing with us!