NASA Initiates Pioneering Inquiry into Initial Aircraft Mishap on Mars

NASA Initiates Pioneering Inquiry into Initial Aircraft Mishap on Mars


# Reflecting on Ingenuity’s Final Flight: Trailblazing the Future of Martian Aviation

NASA’s Ingenuity Mars Helicopter achieved what was once a mere aspiration — performing powered, controlled flight on a different planet. Originally intended as a technology validation to carry out five test flights over a span of 30 days, Ingenuity far surpassed its goals, securing a place in the annals of history. Over almost three years, it completed 72 flights, traversing more than 30 times the intended distance and amassing over two hours of flight time on the Red Planet.

On January 18, 2024, Ingenuity commenced its 72nd and concluding flight. Although the mission ended with an unexpected hard landing, the data collected during its groundbreaking journey is poised to motivate future exploration initiatives and influence the design of upcoming Mars vehicles.

## **Final Flight Details: The Reflection on Flight 72**

The objective for Ingenuity’s last flight was straightforward: a brief vertical ascent to evaluate the performance of its systems and capture images of the surrounding landscape. Ingenuity ascended to an altitude of 40 feet (12 meters), hovered, and photographed the Jezero Crater area it had previously surveyed alongside the Perseverance rover. Nineteen seconds into the mission, the helicopter started its descent, reaching the Martian ground at 32 seconds.

However, this landing marked the end for Ingenuity. Although communication with the helicopter was briefly lost following the touchdown, it was restored the following day, allowing the mission teams to retrieve crucial data. Six days after the flight, images showcased the damage incurred: Ingenuity’s rotor blades had fractured due to the unanticipated impact with the rugged Martian surface.

## **Investigating the Hard Landing**

NASA engineers launched an inquiry to determine the reason behind the failure during Flight 72. Ingenuity’s lead pilot, Håvard Grip, acknowledged the challenges of conducting an accident probe from 100 million miles away, given the absence of onboard recorders or human witnesses. Nevertheless, the available data suggested a significant problem — the limitations of the helicopter’s vision-based navigation system.

Ingenuity’s navigation mechanism relied on a downward-facing camera to monitor surface features, gauging its speed in relation to the Martian ground. This system was engineered for terrain with distinct characteristics — pebbles, rocks, and other recognizable elements — yet relatively even. While it performed impeccably in prior flights, the final mission occurred in a sector of Jezero Crater characterized by sand ripples and other undistinguished landforms.

About 20 seconds into Flight 72, the navigation system reportedly lost its capability to identify enough surface details, leading to erroneous speed data. Consequently, the helicopter landed at high horizontal velocities. NASA’s analysis revealed that the abrupt impact with the uneven sand ripple caused Ingenuity to pitch and roll, creating forces that surpassed the rotor blades’ design tolerances. All four blades fractured, with additional damage to the rotor system causing excessive vibrations and power demands. This ultimately resulted in the mission’s conclusion as Ingenuity lost contact.

## **Future Takeaways**

While grounded, Ingenuity’s influence on Mars exploration endures. Engineers are utilizing flight and engineering data collected from the helicopter to enhance designs for forthcoming Mars aerial vehicles. Ingenuity itself continues to operate to a limited extent, relaying weather and avionics data to the Perseverance rover on a weekly basis. This meteorological data proves critical for grasping the Martian environment, while avionics findings contribute to the evolution of sophisticated rotorcraft.

A notable innovation from the mission is its deployment of commercial, off-the-shelf cellphone processors. In contrast to conventional space hardware, which tends to be heavier, bulkier, and meticulously radiation-hardened, Ingenuity’s lightweight electronics have functioned successfully in Mars’ severe environment for nearly four years. “We became the first mission to incorporate commercial off-the-shelf cellphone processors in deep space,” remarked Teddy Tzanetos, the project manager for Ingenuity. “This illustrates that not everything has to be larger, heavier, and radiation-hardened to operate in extreme planetary conditions.”

Motivated by Ingenuity’s achievements, NASA engineers have initiated the design of the Mars Chopper, a next-generation rotorcraft concept. The Chopper is expected to be around 20 times heavier than Ingenuity and capable of autonomously transporting multiple pounds of scientific payloads while exploring remote Martian areas. Its proposed range — up to 2 miles (3 kilometers) in a single day — would greatly exceed the humble accomplishments of its predecessor, which reached a maximum distance of 2,310 feet (704 meters) during its longest flight.

“Ingenuity has provided us with the assurance and information to conceptualize the future of flight on Mars,” expressed Tzanetos.

## **The Legacy of Ingenuity**

Ingenuity will be celebrated as a pioneer in the realm of Mars exploration,