Envision a colossal structure capable of containing billions of suns’ worth of material, yet emitting no light whatsoever. Astronomers have now verified the existence of such an entity: a spherical gas cloud situated near the spiral galaxy Messier 94, approximately 16 million light-years away, which should have formed a galaxy but has never ignited a single star.
The entity, referred to as Cloud-9, was initially detected by China’s Five-hundred-meter Aperture Spherical Telescope through its signature of cold hydrogen. Radio observations identified the gas but were unable to ascertain whether faint stars were concealed within. Comprehensive imaging from Hubble’s Advanced Camera for Surveys has now conclusively answered this question. There are no stars. Objects that seemed to reside within Cloud-9’s confines were found to be distant background galaxies – comparable to illuminating a dimly lit house only to reveal it was perpetually unoccupied.
This designation makes Cloud-9 the first confirmed instance of what theorists term a RELHIC: a Reionization-Limited H I Cloud. These are anticipated remnants from the early universe – dark matter halos that gathered gas but were never sufficiently massive to overcome the intense radiation that flooded space during the cosmic dawn. Discovering one intact is akin to uncovering a pristine foundation stone remaining from the construction of the local universe.
The Physics of Failure
Cloud-9 exists within a narrow cosmic sweet spot. Its hydrogen core stretches approximately 4,900 light-years and comprises about a million solar masses of gas. However, the manner in which this gas remains coherent reveals a more intriguing narrative. Calculations indicate that the cloud resides within a dark matter halo weighing around five billion solar masses – significantly more than what the visible gas alone could account for.
Had the cloud been considerably more massive, gravity would have compressed the gas until nuclear fusion commenced. Conversely, had it been much smaller, the ionizing radiation from the early universe would have either eradicated the gas completely or excessively heated it to remain bound. Instead, Cloud-9 occupies the brink where it could persist for billions of years without collapsing into stars or dissipating into space.
“In science, we typically learn more from failures than from successes,” notes Alejandro Benitez-Llambay, the principal investigator of the study at the University of Milan-Bicocca. “In this instance, the absence of stars is what substantiates the theory.”
For researchers, this emptiness holds significant scientific value. Typical galaxies contain stars whose light and supernovae continually agitate the surrounding gas, complicating the isolation of the underlying dark matter’s behavior. Cloud-9 presents a cleaner alternative – a laboratory where astronomers can investigate how invisible matter organizes itself on small scales without stellar interference complicating the measurements.
Suburban Survival and Hidden Populations
Cloud-9’s location is crucial to its survival. Situated in what can be described as the galactic suburbs near M94, it escapes the violent tidal forces that would disintegrate it if it were located closer. High-resolution data from the Very Large Array does show slight distortions in the cloud’s shape, likely resulting from ram pressure as it traverses the outer regions of M94’s gaseous halo. This interaction might eventually instigate star formation if the cloud continues to accrete mass, but for now, it remains the purest example of a dark galaxy confirmed to date.
The discovery prompts a more extensive inquiry: how many additional failed galaxies exist, concealed from sight except through radio observations that most surveys aren’t equipped to detect? Theoretical models indicate that these objects should be relatively abundant in the early universe, and many could have persisted to the present day in proximity to larger galaxies. Cloud-9 could merely represent the first of a concealed population that has been orbiting in plain sight, awaiting the ideal blend of radio sensitivity and optical follow-up to unveil their barren interiors.
Future radio surveys with enhanced sensitivity could systematically hunt for similar hydrogen clouds, while space telescopes authenticate their starless nature. Each confirmed instance would help refine models of how the smallest dark matter halos behaved during the universe’s initial billion years – a timeframe when the framework for all subsequent structures was being established, even if not every component ultimately ignited.
The Astrophysical Journal Letters: DOI 10.3847/2041-8213/adae94
There’s no paywall here
If our reporting has enlightened or inspired you, please think about making a donation. Every contribution, regardless of size, enables us to continue providing accurate, engaging, and trustworthy science and medical news. Independent journalism demands time, effort, and resources—your support ensures we can keep revealing the stories that matter most to you.
Join us in making knowledge accessible and impactful. Thank you for supporting us!